For more about Sivan, see
Flying the Flag on Shavout.
With the month of Sivan, the third month of the Jewish
year, we come to the end of the journey that we began two months ago in
Nissan. On Pesach, God took us out of the slavery of Egypt so that we
could become His servants. During the month of Iyar we counted the Omer
and committed ourselves to a daily plan of self-improvement so that we
would be able to successfully take on this exalted role. And now we make
our final preparations for the culminating event in this transformation
of a nation of a slaves into a "kingdom of priests and a holy nation" -
the giving of the Torah.
The giving of the Torah, which we celebrate on Shavuot
(the 6th of Sivan), was a one-time event. As the Rambam (Maimonides)
states in the ninth of his Thirteen Principles of Faith: "I believe with
perfect faith that this Torah will not be exchanged nor will there be
another Torah from the Creator, Blessed is His Name." However the
receiving of the Torah - our acceptance of the Torah as the guiding
principle in our lives - is something that we must make happen every
day.
As we know, giving does not automatically result in
receiving. A teacher can give over information in a class, a parent can
give over a lesson in etiquette and a child can give a schoolmate a
favorite book to read. However, students can refuse to pay attention,
children can rebel and even a friend can be unable to see what's so
special in the book that we find so enthralling. In these cases, the
flow of give and take is cut off.
But when the intended recipient enthusiastically
receives that which is given, a further cycle of giving and receiving is
created. For instance, when a teacher knows that her lessons are being
eagerly listened to, she will be inspired to give even more to her
students.
Although the Torah was given to the world only once,
when we make a commitment to receive its teachings and incorporate them
into our daily lives God responds by giving us a new and deeper level of
understanding. Once we successfully incorporate this deeper
understanding, we are given even more insights.
There is, however, a prerequisite for climbing up this
spiritual ladder. We must first firmly believe that God is the Creator
and the Sustainer of the world and that the Torah is the true expression
of His will. We must be willing to be God's servants and accept the yoke
of His Torah - we must be willing to "do" His will - before we can
receive (or "hear") the rich spiritual insights that making the doing
meaningful.
We Will Do and We Will Hear
When Moses informed the Children of Israel that God
wanted to give them the Torah, they replied: "We will do and we will
hear" (Na'aseh ve'nishmah, Exodus, 24:7).
As commentators on the Torah have pointed out, the
Jewish people appear to have gotten things mixed up. Usually before a
person is willing to embark on a course of action, she wants to first
hear the details and read the fine print: what is she expected to give
and what can she expect to get in return, how much will it cost, what
are the guarantees, etc., etc. Only when she is assured that this is,
indeed, a "good deal" will she sign on the dotted line.
But the Jewish people did the exact opposite. First,
they told God that they were committed to doing everything written in
the Torah - they trusted that any "deal" He wanted to give them was,
indeed, a "good deal." Only after they signed on the dotted line at
Mount Sinai and the contract was already in effect did they ask to be
told what was involved.
How could they have been so rash?
For one thing, God was not exactly an unknown entity to
them. They had seen with their own eyes the plagues that devastated
Egypt and the destruction of the Egyptian army at the Reed Sea. Because
they had seen what happens when a nation willfully goes against God's
will, they were probably hesitant to do the same. And, in fact,
according to one Medrash (allegorical commentary on the Torah), God held
a mountain over the Children of Israel and told them that if they didn't
accept the Torah He would drop the mountain on them and they would die.
Therefore, according to this Medrash, the Jewish people accepted the
Torah out of fear.
However, it is also written that the Jewish people
accepted the Torah with their own free will and that it was a
"knowledgeable" decision. According to the Maggid Meisharim (a
kabbalistic commentary on the Torah based upon the diary of Joseph Caro,
published in Amsterdam, 1708), the generation of Jews who stood at Mount
Sinai were on an extremely exalted spiritual level. Before their souls
came down into this world, they were made familiar with everything
written in the Torah.
Therefore, the Torah was not an unknown entity and their
willing acceptance of it was not based upon "blind faith." When they
said, "We will do," they were saying "We will do everything that we
learned in Heaven." And when they said, "We will hear," they were
saying, "We will hear and study the words of Torah again in this world
so that our bodies will be able to do all that is commanded."
But whether the acceptance of the Torah was done freely,
out of fear or out of some combination of the two, one thing is clear:
When the Jews responded, "We will do and we will hear," they raised
themselves to a spiritual level that was previously unknown in this
world - and which has not been replicated since.
According to the Talmud, when Israel said, "We will do
and we will hear," a heavenly voice proclaimed: "Who has revealed to My
children this secret, which the ministering angels use, as it is
written, 'Bless the Lord, O His angels, mighty creatures who do His
bidding, ever listening to His word' (Psalms 103:20) - first
doing, then listening?" (Shabbat 88a).
It is a great accomplishment for people made of flesh
and blood to reach the spiritual levels of angels who always do God's
will. And yet there is a paradox here, for even though angels are on a
very high spiritual level, they are there because they have no free
will. They are programmed, so to speak, to perform God's will and they
act only when they hear God's instructions. In addition, they can only
do that which God has instructed them to do - they can neither change
His instructions nor refrain from doing His will.
People, on the other hand, have free will - and they
were given this gift of free will by God Himself. Is it therefore such a
good thing for human beings to cast aside this gift?
Most of the nations of the world think not. God offered
His Torah to all the nations of the world, but the vast majority of them
refused to accept it. They insisted on looking over the Torah first and
when they came to a part they didn't like (don't murder, don't steal,
don't commit adultery, etc.) they politely said to God, "No thanks."
Only one people understood that what God wanted people
to do with His gift of free will was to subjugate their will to the will
of God - to accept all of His Torah without any reservations - the
Jewish people.
The nations have not forgotten that they once had the
chance to be the "Chosen People," but that they refused the role. Which
perhaps explains why the nations have assigned to themselves the task of
being the watchdogs for the Jewish people. If they cannot play the part
themselves, at least they can be the eternal critics of God's Chosen
People - critics who are always on the lookout for instances of when the
Jews fail to perform God's will and fall from their high level of
emulating the angels.
Do But Don't Hear, Hear But Don't Do
Throughout history, two of Israel's greatest critics
have been Esau and Ishmael, and as we shall see, this is no accident.
In Zera Barech, a 17th century
commentary on the Torah by Barachiah Barech Shapira, it is pointed out
that there is a connection between the language of "We will do and we
will hear" and the names of Esau and Ishmael.
Esau was Abraham's grandson and Jacob's twin brother and
he is considered to be the ancestor of the European nations. His name is
a cognate of the Hebrew word la'asot, which means "to do."
Ishmael was Abraham's son by the Egyptian concubine
Hagar, and he is the ancestor of the Arab nations. (However, because one
of Esau's wives was one of Ishmael's daughters, it is hard to know today
who is actually a true descendent of Ishmael and who is a genetic mix of
the two). The name Ishmael comes from the Hebrew word l'shmoah
- "to hear."
Although this linguistic connection was made more than
three hundred years ago, we can see how this connection is played out in
today's news.
The European nations have taken upon themselves the role
of being the moral judges of the world. Being "rational" people, they
would never dream of looking into the Torah to "hear" what God says
constitutes a moral society. Instead they rely upon their own wisdom,
and this wisdom has led them to believe (again!) that the problems of
the world are caused by the Jewish people.
It "naturally" follows that it is up to Europe to punish
the Jewish people for their wrongdoing (both real and imagined), and in
this role they are busy "doing" many things against Israel. For
instance, they erect courts in Belgian to try Israel leaders as "war
criminals"; they establish boycotts in Norway against Israeli products;
they create petitions to oust Israeli professors and doctors from
international organizations; they establish United Nations "commissions
of inquiry" whose sole purpose is to charge Israel with crimes that
Israel didn't commit, etc.
Yes, Europe, the descendants of Esau, is terribly busy
these days doing many things. Yet there is one thing that they are
emphatically not doing - listening. Because they have already accused,
tried and sentenced the Jewish people in their so-called courts of moral
justice, the Europeans are unable to hear the truth and listen to
reason. They are the people who say, "Don't bother me with the facts
because I have already made up mind."
A striking instance of this was the European community's
reaction to the so-called massacre in Jenin. Even when their own
official agencies confirmed there was no massacre in Jenin - and it was
proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that the supposed massacre was an
outright lie willfully fed to the media by the Palestinians - the
Europeans have adamantly stuck to their guns: the Jews were the bad guys
in this battle between two fully armed forces and the Palestinians were
the good guys.
Since their moral standards and their system of justice
is a reflection of their own distorted notions, the Europeans are not
interested in listening to any evidence that contradicts their beliefs.
They only use their faculty of hearing when they are presented with more
lies that confirm what they already believe.
The Arabs, on the other hand, are good listeners. They
have learned from their prophets that there is a God. And by listening
to the Jews, they know that the tiny sliver of land called Israel is
holy. They have also heard about the Holocaust, the American Revolution,
the siege of Leningrad and many other things. The Arabs are good
students who hear everything that is going on in the "world history"
class. But what do they "do" with what they have heard? Do they take
these lessons and use them to create a good and just society for their
people? Unfortunately, they do not. Instead they use what they have
heard to create a tangle of lies that makes a mockery of the concepts of
holiness, justice and human rights.
They turn the God Who asks us to "choose life" into a
God Who applauds the suicide bomber for the death and destruction he
causes. They liken their own corrupt gang of terrorists and thieves who
mercilessly oppress their own people to the American leaders who drafted
the American Constitution and the Bill of Rights. They claim that the
explosive population growth their people have experienced during the
last few decades is actually a "holocaust."
When Europe's "We will do" is joined to the Arab's "We
will hear," the result is a farce with tragic consequences. The Arab
"freedom fighters" - a conceptual mirage created from a motley
compilation of all the victors and victims in world history - are kept
going by a steady stream of European money and weapons. The result is
more carnage and destruction for the sake of carnage and destruction -
something that Europe, with two world wars to its credit, does very
well. But thanks to the public relations spin manufactured by the
ever-glib Arabs, carnage and the willful destruction of innocent human
life becomes transformed into actions that lead to peace and the
protection of human rights. Which in turn gives the Europe the green
light to fund even more acts of terror.
Although one might think that combining Europe's "We
will do" with the Arabs "We will hear" would equal Sinai, in truth their
unholy alliance is a far cry from the "We will do and we will hear"
spoken by the Jewish people.
The Struggle of Give and Take
How does Israel fit into this linguistic equation? The
name "Israel" is often translated as "He who struggles with God." On the
surface the name seems rather uncomplimentary. Wouldn't it be better to
be named "He who accepts God" or "He who loves God"? Yet in some cases,
a little moral struggling can be a good thing.
At Mount Sinai, the Jewish people accepted upon
themselves the notion of accountability. We cannot just take the Torah
and then "do" whatever we feel is right. Our actions have to be checked
and double-checked against the teachings we have "heard" in the Torah.
On the other hand, we cannot just passively receive the Torah - hear its
words when we sit in synagogue or in the classroom and then go out and
do whatever we please in "the real world." We are commanded to "be" a
holy nation - which is a synthesis of doing and hearing. We must
internalize the teachings of the Torah that have been given to us so
that we can do good in each and every one of our interactions with the
world.
This idea of synthesis is perhaps hinted out in the
famous phrase describing the Jews' arrival at Mount Sinai. Whereas
before their wanderings and their encampments were described in the
plural ("They wandered." "They encamped."), when the people get to Mount
Sinai it says, "Israel [in the singular] encamped there in front of the
mountain" (Exodus 19:2).
Our Sages explain that this means that the Jewish people
agreed to put aside their differences and that they were of one heart.
They all agreed to accept all of the Torah and so there was no such
thing as some of the people saying "we will do," while others said, "we
will hear."
This commitment to do and to hear all that is written in
God's Torah was imprinted upon the soul of every Jew as an individual
and upon the Jewish nation as a whole. "We will do and we will hear" has
given us a system of checks and balances that has allowed us to maintain
our moral compass throughout our 3,000-year-old history. It is what has
allowed us to live amongst murderers without becoming murderers
ourselves and to retain a clear vision of the truth in a world that is
obscured by a fog of lies.
And so as we commemorate the Giving of the Torah this
Shavuot, we should all make an effort to remember the phrase that
signaled the completion of our transformation from a nation of slaves to
a holy nation and enthusiastically say, "We will do and we will hear."
By subjugating our will to His will - by making His vision of a just and
moral world our own vision - may it be His will to fulfill the blessings
of His Torah and grant all of Am Yisrael long life and peace.
Chag Shavuot Sameach (Happy Shavuot)!