On the 17th of Tamuz we enter into the
saddest period of the Jewish calendar - the Three Weeks of mourning that
culminate in the fast day that commemorates the destruction of the First
and Second Temples - Tisha B'Av.
The 17th of Tamuz is itself a fast day, since
this is when the walls of Jerusalem were first breached. It is also a
day of self-reflection because, as our Sages say, in any generation
where the Temple is not rebuilt, it is as if the Temple was destroyed in
that generation.
To understand how we might be responsible today for the
delay in rebuilding the Temple, and learn what we can do to hasten its
rebuilding, it is helpful to go back to the incident where the troubles
began: the bad report of the Land of Israel given by the 12 spies, which
can be found in B'Midbar (Numbers), Chapter 13.
ERROR MESSAGE!
According to the great 19th century sage
Rabbi Meir Leib ben Yechiel Michael, who is known as the Malbim, there
was an error in comprehension from the very start of the mission. When
God tells Moshe to "Send out men for you" to go into the Land of Israel,
the Hebrew verb T-U-R is used and not R-G-L.
T-U-R means to tour or to explore. R-G-L
means to spy. What's the difference?
God was telling Moshe that the mission of the 12 men was
to explore the Land of Israel so that they could determine where to
build their cities and where to establish their farms. How they were
going to conquer the land was not an issue for them to worry about,
because God had already promised them that the land would be theirs.
Their one and only job was to determine where within the land they
wanted to establish their dwelling places.
The act of spying, on the other hand, has a very
different purpose. Countries send out spies to try to get a hold of
another country's military secrets because they fear that without this
information they will be at a disadvantage should a conflict arise.
Although spies are used to bolster a country's security, the need for
them implies a lack of security.
Since the Children of Israel already had a sure-fire
advantage over the inhabitants of the Land of Israel - namely God's
guarantee that they would be successful in the conquest - there was no
need to send "spies." Therefore, when the 12 men chosen for the task of
going to the Land of Israel changed their assignment from one of
exploration to one of spying, they displayed a deep lack of
comprehension of what was expected of them.
Yet what was so terrible about not understanding the
Divine command? Don't we all sometimes mistakes? Why should the entire
Jewish People have had to endure 2,000 years of exile because of one
mistake made by 12 men?
The answer to this question must lie within the nature
of the mistake itself. As we know, there is a difference between an
intentional transgression and an unintentional one - and the punishment
differs for outright rebellion and mistakes that are made because we
lack the knowledge to know the difference between what is right and what
is wrong in God's eyes.
However, there is also another type of transgression -
one that lies within the gray area that separates knowing intention from
unconscious action. When we are guilty of this type of transgression, we
have mistakenly convinced ourselves that a wrong action is really
something that is God's will. We have allowed intentional
rationalization to lead us into unintentional rebellion.
What sort of transgression did the spies commit? To find
out, we must take a look at the events that led up to their mission.
Secret Agents or Agents of Secrets?
The Ohr Hachaim, Rabbi Chaim ben Atar (18th
century kabbalist and sage), sheds an interesting light on the incident
of the 12 spies. He points out that when a person represents someone
else he becomes affected by that other person's thoughts and values.
A salesperson, for instance, is an agent for a company.
To be successful, the salesperson must believe that the company's
products are beneficial. If the product really is beneficial - well and
good. But what if the product is actually harmful to the health, or what
if the company is involved in a scam operation that is bilking innocent
people of their money? If the agent badly needs the job, she will have
to internalize the skewed values of the company and with time she may
not even be able to see that she is doing anything wrong.
When the Children of Israel left Egypt, a group of
people known as the "Mixed Multitude" left with them. This mixed
multitude was on a very low level spiritually. For them, the events of
the Exodus were not pathways to spiritual growth that would lead them
closer to God, they were just a "way-out" of a bad situation. At the
first moment of difficulty in the desert - which they interpreted as
being just another bad situation that needed to gotten out of, and not
as an opportunity to develop emunah (faith) and bitachon
(trust in God) - they immediately began to complain.
"We're thirsty! We want water! We're hungry! We want
meat and melons and onions and garlic!"
And if the service provided by God, via His servants
Moshe and Aaron, wasn't fast enough, this mixed multitude had a ready
answer:
"Let's go back to Egypt! Now!"
The lack of emunah and the constant grumbling of
these malcontents had a very demoralizing impact on the rest of the
people - including the men who were sent to explore the Land of Israel.
Although the 12 men selected for the mission were of the
highest caliber, only two of them - Joshua and Calev - were
wholehearted. The other ten men carried within their hearts the doubts
and fears of the mixed multitude and by the time they got to the Land of
Israel, the whispers of doubt had turned into a thunderous roar.
What Fear Can Do
God had told the people that the land He was giving them
was a land filled with bounty and blessing. However, when the spies
arrived in the land they thought they were seeing a land of destruction
and bizarre phenomena.
The fruit growing there was so big that it took two
grown men to carry a cluster of grapes. Wherever they turned, they saw
the inhabitants of the land weeping and wailing as they went to bury
their dead. Very strange, indeed.
If the spies had planted the words of God's promise
firmly in their hearts, they would have been able to correctly interpret
what they were seeing.
"Wow! Look at how big that cluster of grapes is! This
land really is a land of bounty"
"See how God is protecting us so we can accomplish our
mission. He has arranged things so that the land's inhabitants will be
so busy burying their dead that they won't notice us! This really is a
land where we will be protected by His blessing."
What happened instead, as we know from the spies' report
that is recorded in the Torah, is that they gave more credence to the
fears of the mixed multitude than the promise of God.
"These gigantic fruits are unnatural! There must be
something perverse about this land," they said.
"This is a land that eats its inhabitants. Everywhere we
went, we say nothing but death and mourning."
The spies did not set out with the intention of ignoring
God's words, and so the transgression they made when they defamed the
Land of Israel through their erroneous report was not an intentional
rebellion. Yet because they were all righteous and learned men, their
transgression could not be called purely unintentional. They knew that
the people who were filled with fears and doubts were on a much lower
spiritual rung, and they still allowed themselves to be guided by their
poor attitude.
The consequence was that their interpretation of events
was tragically flawed. Instead of trying to fit what they observed into
the framework of "bounty and blessing," they interpreted everything they
experienced in a negative way. And the only way they could rationalize
this skewed version of reality was to leave God out of the picture.
When they returned to the Israelite camp, they did
concede that the land flowed with milk and honey. However, they went on
to say that, "We are not able to go up against the people; for they are
stronger than we are."
Without God, their evaluation of the security situation
was perhaps 100 percent accurate. But this crucial omission rendered
their opinions 100 percent worthless.
Unfortunately, the ten spies succeeded in convincing the
rest of the people that only death and destruction awaited them in the
"good" land that God had promised them. The battle cry of what had
previously been the fringe - "Let's go back to Egypt" - was now the
rallying cry of the many.
It was only Moshe's passionate plea that saved the
people from being destroyed by God's wrath. Yet even though God did
forgive the people, what had been done could not be undone. The people
cried all night and engaged in sincere repentance, but God did not
rescind His decree: that generation was condemned to die off in the
wilderness and it was their children who inherited the land.
When "I'm Sorry" Is Not Enough
Some of the people could not accept that saying "I'm
sorry" was not enough to change the decree. The next morning they
organized their own army and set off to conquer the land. They were
immediately defeated.
Why wasn't their teshuva (repentance) accepted?
Sometimes opportunities come along that are only offered
once, or only offered in a specific time frame. This happens all the
time in the business world, where the opportunity to get in on the
ground floor of the next hot investment is only offered for a short
period of time. It also happens in a woman's life, where her ability to
have children is controlled by her biological clock.
The Children of Israel had been given several
opportunities to show that they were spiritually ready to enter into the
Land of Israel - and each time they failed. Because a part of their
hearts was still enslaved by Egyptian culture and values, they were
unable to muster up the bitachon (trust in God) that was a
prerequisite for settling the Land.
Saying "I'm sorry" averted the decree of death, but it
could not change the fact that they had denied God's providence over the
world. Because they had doubted God's ability to safely bring them into
the Land of Israel, there had been a limiting of God's glory in the
world.
For that offence there was not - and still isn't - an
erasing of the transgression that leads to complete forgiveness.
A Night of Crying - and Laughing
The night that the ten spies delivered their evil report
was the night of Tisha B'Av. Because the people cried for no reason -
they could have listened to the good report given by Yehoshua and Calev
instead - God decreed that this night should be a night of crying for
the generations. And, indeed, the two Temples were destroyed on this
night.
Yet within the tears there is hope, for we know that
soon the Temple will be rebuilt. How can we do our part to hasten its
construction and usher in an era of world peace?
First, we must understand that our job is not to spy out
God's world. Everything we need to know about living a good life - a
life that is filled with bounty and blessing - is contained in God's
Torah. Yes, we are commanded to "explore" the Torah - to study it and
internalize its teachings so that we can live by it. But we should never
think that God isn't wise enough to know what's best for us or strong
enough to protect us from harm - or fear that He has left us alone in
the world to fend for ourselves.
Second, we have to recognize that there is a "mixed
multitude" residing inside all of us. These are the worries and fears
that prevent us from opening up to God's kindness and protection. If we
allow our lives to be dominated by worry, we will have what to worry
about, because the Talmud promises us that, "A person is led along the
path that he chooses to travel upon." If, however, we truly believe in
God's promise that the Land - and all of life - is bountiful and full of
blessing, we will become agents for bringing this bounty and blessing
into the world.
Third, we have to realize that our actions do have
consequences. Every day that we disregard the mitzvos
(commandments) of the Torah is another day when God's glory is
diminished in His creation. Every time that we diminish other people
through gossip or treat Shabbat with disrespect, we are diminishing the
amount of holy light that can shine into the world - and delaying the
rebuilding of the Temple for one more day.
However, because we are told that Tisha B'Av will one
day become a day of laughter and celebration, we know that we are not
condemned to repeat the error of the ten spies and the Children of
Israel. We can merit to rebuild the Temple - and by resolving to follow
God's Torah with a joyous and whole heart, we can start rebuilding it
today.
May the fasting and prayers and meditations that we
offer to God on the 17th of Tamuz be accepted, and may we
merit to see the rebuilding of the Temple now and at once.